Kevin H.
I totally understand your point. This stuff is CONFUSING! Mostly it messes with our mind if we grow up learning about music from a western mind’s teaching. From classical to pop music we are taught that a song goes a certain way and when you write it on paper it should be written exactly how you heard it right?
But try to remember and try to imagine some traditions have a totally different way to create their songs.
Here are some steps you might think about taking to get closer to this.
If you want to learn Aiya bushi…(in 6 steps)
Step one.
Don’t worry about the Shamisen part…listen ONLY to the song.
Step two .
Study the music as written on paper.
Step three.
Go back and listen to many different Shamisen players as they play along to singers. Study the way the Shamisen fits the singing.
Step four.
Next, go and listen only to solo versions of the tune as played on Shamisen.
Step 5.
Make a list of all the ways you hear people playing it differently and make a point to find the “best ones” …the ones you like the most.
Step 6 .
Take all the parts from different peoples Aiya bushi that you liked and fit them together to make your own Aiya bushi.
The reason it never comes close to what you see on paper is because the point everyone is trying to get is to make it totally different from something written on paper. It’s all about creating your own Aiya bushi in the end. It’s never about copying the paper score music exactly like it is.
But the secret is to know the song. The singing part. The melody!
That is the only part you need to know completely. Everything else on the Shamisen is made up. Sometimes the best players don’t even have a plan . They make up a whole Aiya bushi right on the spot.
That’s the goal of Tsugaru Shamisen. To know the tunes so well that you can create a Shamisen part out of thin air anytime, anyplace!