That’s a great point by Kevin. I think amazing musicianship and hilarious joke telling require the same skill - Emotion!
I might’ve mentioned this before, but a few years ago, our honky tonk group (The Abbott Brothers) was joined by a 16 year old violin prodigy. Amazingly good, but neither his face nor his playing had expression. My friend in the audience was almost regretful. He could see the kid was good, but didn’t feel anything because the he was like a statue.
Many bluegrass friends I know spend hours a day practicing their riffs and licks, thinking that the better you play, the better a performer you are. On the other hand, I’ve been thoroughly entertained by players half as proficient, but their emotion is pouring through their instrument. They’re giving it all they have, and that is the spark! Though we may not all know the same musics or the same art, I think all of us connect when the artist can express their emotion through their craft.
Comedians are the same way. You can make a science out of comedic timing and setting up punchlines, but what really makes a comedian stand out is the emotion they give. Comedians like Kevin Hart or Bill Burr (personal favorites) have great timing and tell stories hilariously, but what also adds depth is the emotion they express. Amid laughing at their stories, you can almost feel their frustrations in life.
So, what’s my point… ah yes! Though I’m not ‘denouncing’ striving for proficiency, I do think the effort to connect one’s emotions through their craft is an often overlooked aspect of art, but is more influential than actual proficiency. The best part is, there’s no right or wrong way to express emotions. Like comedians, their personalities are all different! You can express happiness, confusion, calmness, rage, anything you’re feeling at the moment! When you figure out how to connect your feelings to your craft, it won’t require practice, and we can all feel it instantly, because if there’s one thing that connects us social creatures together, it’s emotion.
Owari!